If Better Abdominal Muscles Are Your New Year's Resolution, Try This
Sunday, December 31, 2006
Healthline
Readers have been writing to ask about the conflicting reports in fitness magazines on how often you should work your abs. Some sources cite research studies saying you should rest between resistance training. Other articles say to exercise them every day.
It's common to debate fiber type and fatigue and conclude whether to schedule your abs daily or intermittently. Then people "do" abdominal exercise based on that, and completely neglect what abdominal muscles really do when you stand up and go about your daily life.
Abdominal muscles have their main function when you are standing. They do not automatically do anything to support your back or prevent lower back pain. The 'support' comes from how you stand. It has nothing to do with strengthening or tightening. Those are common fallacies.
Abdominal muscles attach from your hips to your ribs. When you use abdominal muscles, you prevent the distance between ribs and hip from lengthening, which bends the lower back, pinching it back like a soda straw. The article Fixing the Commonest Source of Mystery Lower Back Pain shows how this works. Abdominal muscles are like a guy wire attached to the front of a tree, keeping the tree from bending or leaning backward. Your abdominal muscles do not prevent leaning backward automatically, you need to deliberately use them to move to neutral spine. If you are not using your abs when you stand, your upper body will lean backward and/or your hip will tilt downward in front. This is called slouching. Your lower back overly curves inward too much, and pinches and pressures the joints and soft tissue of your lower back.
People who overly arch the lower back (called swayback and hyperlordosis) usually notice their back hurts after long standing, walking, running, and reaching and lifting overhead. They feel they need to lean forward or sit to relieve it. The bending over forward feels good at the moment because you stop the pinching backward that causes the pain. It is not a "fix" - it does not stop you from going right back to hyperlordotic slouching that causes the pain when you stand back up. Strengthening and stretches also are not the "fix" for this back pain. You can prevent the pain in the first place by not slouching in hyperlordosis. Then you will get built-in use of your abdominal muscles, and not need a temporary, palliative, stop-gap measure of bending over forward, or picking up one leg.
Using your abs doesn't mean sucking them in or making them tight. It means not letting your lower back overly-arch. When you tilt or tuck your hip under you to straighten your pelvis to upright rather than tilted, and bring your upper body to upright position rather than tilting backward, the muscles that reduce the overly large inward curve to neutral are your abdominal muscles. That is how abdominal muscles support your back - when you deliberately use them to stop slouching.
Plenty of people have 6-pack abs and have terrible posture and continuing back pain. In my practice, I treat patients with strong well-defined muscles who hurt their back opening windows because they overly-arch the lower back when they reach upward and lift overhead.
If "abs" are part of your New Year's Resolution, here is how to get functional healthy abdominal exercise:
- Stop doing crunches. They are not functional, not healthy, and don't train your abs the way you really need them to work in real life.
- Instead of crunches, try the plank to practice and challenge healthy positioning, described in the post Change Common Exercises to Get Better Ab Exercise and Stop Back Pain.
- Stand properly without overarching. That gives built-in abdominal muscles exercise all the time. Do not suck in or tighten. Just position your spine away from unhealthy overarching.
Book:
Related:
- What Abdominal Muscles Don't Do - The Missing Link
- Using Abdominal Muscles is Not Tightening or Pressing Navel to Spine
- Holiday Leg and Abdominal Exercise
- Prevent Back Surgery
---
Read success stories and send your own.
See if your answers are already here - click Fitness Fixer labels, links, archives, and Index.
For personal medical questions - Replies to Medical Questions.
Limited Class space for personal feedback. Top students may earn certification through DrBookspan.com/Academy. More fun in Dr. Bookspan's Books.
Read success stories and send your own.
See if your answers are already here - click Fitness Fixer labels, links, archives, and Index.
For personal medical questions - Replies to Medical Questions.
Limited Class space for personal feedback. Top students may earn certification through DrBookspan.com/Academy. More fun in Dr. Bookspan's Books.
---
Labels: abdominal muscles, facet joints, fix pain, lordosis, lower back, posture, strength, upper back
3 Comments:
At Monday, January 01, 2007 1:02:00 AM, Anonymous said…
I found your better abdominal muscles article so interesting. I was one of these people who for years did 100 crunches a day thinking that they would strengthen my back and take away the pain. Not so. I have been following your Better Abdominal Muscles advice for a year now, it just being part of my every day life....the bonus being no more back pain.
I have also taken your advice re using your body weight to keep strong. I am taking it slowly and look forward to a stronger upper body.
Thank you Dr Jolie for all the wonderful advice.
At Monday, January 08, 2007 2:11:00 AM, Healthline said…
Ivy, thank you for good words and good work. I have enjoyed following you apply each new exercise with each of your comments. You keep getting healthier and stronger. Have fun with the new upper body strengthening. It will make every day activities feel better and easier. Are you doing handstands against the wall? I am imagining things upside down in New Zealand :-)
At Wednesday, December 10, 2008 1:18:00 PM, Unknown said…
finally someone educated has said what i have thought for a long time. I have always tried to suck in my abs or tighten them but neither one worked and they only mad my movements stiffer and less efficient. Just holding your spine in the correct position works a lot better. I have one question though? why do people go around telling people to "pull your navel to the spine" if it doesn't work? Don't they know it doesn't work? Haven't they tried it.
Post a Comment
<< Home